Monday, March 11, 2013

Rational Beings

Kant pgs. 32-36



Conclusion: The categorical imperative, according to the will of a rational being, must treat all as ends, not just means to ends.


EP1: The will determines itself to action while following certain laws (35)

IP1: This is a principle and or quality of a rational being.

EP2: Every man is a rational being

IP2: Every rational being is an end in him or herself, and must always be considered as such.

EP3: The nature of rational beings defines them as ends in themselves. (36)

EP4: As a result, rational beings cannot be used for subjective ends because rational beings are objective ends. (36)

IP3: By nature, rational beings are ends and subsequently cannot be substituted with another nature (i.e. subjective end, or a means to an end)

EP5: Rational beings cannot serve as means otherwise nothing of absolute value would exist. (36) Example

EP6: The Suicidal Man asks himself if suicide can be in accordance with the idea of humanity as an end in itself.(36)

EP6a: If the man dies he is using himself as a means to a more comfortable state until the end of his life (36)

EP6b: Man is not merely an object and cannot be used as such.(36)

IP4: If man were a means then suicide or killing for the sake of improving ones stature would hold moral value.

Thus: The categorical imperative, according to the will of a rational being, must treat all as ends, not just means to ends.